An author on Anderson Cooper’s CNN program Thursday said the United States is uniquely obligated to maintain air links with the Ebola-ridden nation of Liberia, claiming it would be immoral to quarantine a nation created through “American slavery.”
Since the first U.S.-diagnosed case of Ebola cropped up earlier this week in Dallas, calls to ban flights from Ebola outbreak zones — particularly Liberia, where the patient contracted the virus – have exploded in American media.
But David Quammen, author of Ebola, believes the past sins of the United States require it to maintain travel links with the nation, despite the possible health consequences.
“We in America, how dare we turn our backs on Liberia, given the fact that this is a country that was founded in the 1820s, 1830s because of American slavery?” he told Cooper. “We have a responsibility to stay connected with them, and help them see this through.”
Beginning in 1820, thousands of freed African-American slaves colonized a patch of western Africa with the help of prominent American abolitionists. They named that nation ”Liberia,” modeling their flag and political institutions after the United States.
******************* “You have no responsibility to live up to what other people think you ought to accomplish. I have no responsibility to be like they expect me to be. It's their mistake, not my failing.” ¯ Richard P. Feynman
His history is somewhat correct but the conclusion he draws from it is in error.
“We have a responsibility to stay connected with them, and help them see this through.”
It does not follow that because we have an historical connection with Liberia (what about the other effected countries?) and the fact America has greater technical capacity than Liberia to deal with Ebola, it does not follow we ought allow the disease to possibly spread beyond its current locations. In that way lies madness. Liberia and the other nations can be helped without risking the spread of the disease beyond West Africa.
I would also like to ask: why just us? Isn't this a worldwide concern? Where are the UN and the other countries of the world sending in their troops, their medical and aid personnel? It might be happening but not on the scale demanded of the US. Liberia may have been created by us, though with good intent, but it was the nations of Europe which conducted the slave trade and colonized Africa. So where are they?
If ISIS Is Not Islamic, then the Inquisition Was Not Catholic~~Jerry Coyne at NewRepublic.com
Quote: Cincinnatus wrote in post #2His history is somewhat correct but the conclusion he draws from it is in error.
“We have a responsibility to stay connected with them, and help them see this through.”
It does not follow that because we have an historical connection with Liberia (what about the other effected countries?) and the fact America has greater technical capacity than Liberia to deal with Ebola, it does not follow we ought allow the disease to possibly spread beyond its current locations. In that way lies madness. Liberia and the other nations can be helped without risking the spread of the disease beyond West Africa.
I would also like to ask: why just us? Isn't this a worldwide concern? Where are the UN and the other countries of the world sending in their troops, their medical and aid personnel? It might be happening but not on the scale demanded of the US. Liberia may have been created by us, though with good intent, but it was the nations of Europe which conducted the slave trade and colonized Africa. So where are they?
Also where are the Moslem nations. The European slave trade would not have existed without Moslem slavers rounding up Africans and delivering them to waiting European slave ships at ports on the west coast of Africa
Quote: algernonpj wrote in post #3Also where are the Moslem nations. The European slave trade would not have existed without Moslem slavers rounding up Africans and delivering them to waiting European slave ships at ports on the west coast of Africa
Get out of my head.
“We make men without chests and expect from them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honor and are shocked to find traitors in our midst.” C.S. Lewis, The Abolition of Man